Posts

Owner, Challenger, Decider

Image
Making Independent Challenge Count When the CRO and the CIO disagree about a risk, what happens next? It is a useful question to put to any investment governance structure. The answer reveals whether decision authority, risk ownership and independent oversight have been deliberately established or simply assumed. Some institutions point to an escalation procedure. Others describe a culture of open debate. Some maintain that the CRO has the authority to say no. But those answers leave a more fundamental question unresolved. Who owns the risk, who challenges it, and who has the authority to decide? In Risk Ownership Is Not Risk Minimisation , I argued that the risk owner is not necessarily the risk management function. The owner is the individual or body accountable for an exposure, with a defined ability to influence or change it. That distinction raises a further question. If the risk function does not own the exposure, what authority should it have? And how can it provide meaningful i...

Dynamic Risk Before Dynamic Asset Allocation

Image
Why the Risk Decision Must Come Before the Allocation Decision In my last piece , I argued that portfolio construction is the discipline of deciding which trade-offs an institution is willing to own. I ended with a question: when should an institution change how much risk it is willing to take before changing how that risk is expressed through the portfolio? This piece is my answer. When institutions talk about becoming more dynamic, the conversation usually turns quickly to asset allocation. Should we increase equities because valuations have improved? Reduce credit exposure because spreads have compressed? Shift toward real assets because inflation expectations have changed? These are reasonable investment questions. But I believe another question should come first. Has anything changed that justifies taking more or less risk at the total-portfolio level? That question concerns dynamic risk. It is distinct from dynamic asset allocation, and for a long-horizon asset owner, it is often...

Portfolio Construction Is an Exercise in Trade-offs

Image
Why the Best Portfolio Is Not the One That Maximises Any Single Dimension In my last piece , I argued that a risk owner’s job is to keep the institution aligned with the risks it intended to take, not simply to keep risk low. That assumes the institution has already decided which risks it wants to own, and what it is willing to give up to own them. This piece is about how that decision gets made. A portfolio is usually described as a collection of investments. For an asset owner, it is also a collection of trade-offs. More return may require accepting less liquidity. More diversification may add complexity. A strategy that looks attractive in isolation may use governance capacity that is needed elsewhere. A sophisticated implementation may improve expected efficiency while raising fees, operational demands and model dependence, and making it harder to act under stress. None of this makes an investment good or bad. The question is whether the trade-off is worth making for the institutio...

Back to Basics: The Mandate Still Comes First

Image
  I recently attended two investment conferences in London. The topics were quite different. One focused on how asset owners are moving beyond traditional asset allocation toward more adaptive, total-portfolio thinking. The other focused on manager research in private equity and the role of external managers within the broader portfolio. Despite the different subject matter, both discussions led back to the same conclusion: The mandate still comes first. Institutional investment frameworks have become increasingly sophisticated. We spend considerable time on expected returns, factor exposures, liquidity, benchmarks, manager selection, portfolio construction and implementation. All of these are important. But they are downstream decisions. The more fundamental question is what the fund must ultimately achieve. That requires clarity on a small number of issues that should sit at the centre of the investment process:   These are not preliminary questions to be answered once and t...

Risk Ownership Is Not Risk Minimisation

Image
Why Good Risk Governance Must Work in Both Directions In  Governance Is an Investment Advantage , I argued that good governance requires clear ownership of material risks and clear decision rights around them. That raises a harder question: what is the owner actually responsible for? It is tempting to think of risk ownership as keeping exposure below a limit. For a long-term investor, that is too narrow. The objective is not to minimise risk, but to take the amount and type of risk that best serves the institution’s mandate. Sometimes that means reducing exposure. At other times, the harder decision is to take more. By risk owner , I do not necessarily mean the risk-management function. I mean the individual or body with clear accountability for an exposure and a defined path to influence or change it. Depending on the institution, that may sit with the CIO, an investment committee, a total-portfolio function or another designated decision-maker. Ownership Works in Both Directions ...