Beyond Public and Private
Why Risk Exposure and Liquidity Capacity Should Drive Asset Allocation
Once the portfolio is viewed through its underlying economic risks, the distinction between public and private markets starts to look different. Institutional portfolios have traditionally been divided into two broad categories: public markets and private markets.
This distinction has shaped investment organisations, governance, benchmarks, reporting, and career paths. Public and private market teams are usually managed separately, and asset allocation often begins by determining capital allocation between these categories.
The distinction remains operationally important. Public and private investments differ in liquidity, valuation, governance, fees, manager dispersion, transparency, and implementation complexity.
However, from a total portfolio perspective, asset allocation should not begin with the distinction between public and private markets.
The more fundamental questions are:
Which economic risks and return sources should the institution own?
And:
Which implementation approach offers the most effective exposure, considering the institution’s liquidity capacity, tolerance, governance, and objectives?
Looking Beyond Asset-Class Labels
Many private assets share important economic characteristics with their public-market counterparts.
Private equity primarily provides exposure to corporate growth and residual enterprise value. Private credit offers exposure to contractual cash flows, default risk, and recovery outcomes. Infrastructure combines growth, inflation sensitivity, duration, regulatory risk, and operational exposure. Real estate reflects property income, financing conditions, inflation sensitivity, and economic growth.
This does not mean that public and private investments are economically identical.
Private market returns are also affected by leverage, complexity, control rights, company size, manager skill, valuation practices, origination capability, and illiquidity. These factors can significantly change an investment’s risk and return profile.
The key point is that “public” and “private” describe how assets are accessed and traded, but do not fully reflect the underlying economic risks.
Portfolios should therefore be built around underlying risk exposures, not only on asset-class labels.
Start with the Mandate and the Total Portfolio
Asset allocation should begin with the institution’s mandate.
Only after answering these questions should the institution determine which compensated risks to deliberately assume.
These may include:
Private equity, for example, should be considered in the context of the total portfolio’s desired growth exposure and the range of ways that exposure can be implemented. Private credit should similarly be assessed as part of the institution’s broader credit exposure, including where in the capital structure it wants to take risk and through which channels.
From a total portfolio perspective, the more fundamental building blocks are the underlying economic risks. Asset classes are implementation structures through which institutions access combinations of those risks and their associated risk premia.
Liquidity as a Portfolio Constraint and Strategic Resource
Once desired risk exposures are identified, liquidity becomes a central factor in allocation decisions.
Public markets typically provide continuous pricing and immediate access to capital. Private markets often require longer holding periods, uncertain cash flow timing, and limited exit opportunities near reported NAV (Net Asset Value).
This illiquidity may be associated with higher expected returns. Investors may be compensated for longer capital commitments, uncertain distributions, providing financing where capital is scarce, or accepting complexity that others avoid. The expected return differential may compensate investors not only for illiquidity, but also for complexity, leverage, information demands, origination requirements, governance burden and manager-selection risk.
However, an illiquidity premium is neither automatic nor constant.
Not all private assets offer adequate compensation for liquidity, leverage, fees, complexity, and manager risk. Capital inflows, competitive fundraising, and high entry valuations can reduce expected returns. Reported performance may also be influenced by valuation smoothing and delayed mark-to-market adjustments.
The relevant decision is therefore not simply whether an investment is illiquid.
The key question is whether the institution is adequately compensated, on a net and risk-adjusted basis, for all risks assumed.
Liquidity should be considered a scarce strategic resource. Allocating capital to illiquid investments limits the institution’s ability to rebalance, meet liabilities, fund capital calls, post collateral, and pursue future opportunities.
Liquidity Capacity, Tolerance and Appetite
It is important to distinguish among three related concepts.
These concepts should not be used interchangeably.
An institution may have significant liquidity capacity but limited governance tolerance. Another may have a long investment horizon but high collateral or cash-flow needs. A third may have both the capacity and conviction to hold more illiquid assets.
When liquidity capacity and tolerance are high, the institution may allocate more capital to investments that provide attractive compensation for illiquidity, complexity, or long-term commitment.
However, this decision should be based on expected compensation, not on the assumption that private assets consistently deliver superior returns.
Allocating Within Common Risk Exposures
A risk-factor-based approach reframes the comparison between public and private assets.
Instead of viewing public and private equity as separate allocation categories, the institution can assess them as alternative ways to gain growth exposure.
Similarly, rather than considering public bonds, syndicated loans, and private credit separately, the institution can evaluate how each contributes to credit, duration, default, and liquidity risk within the total portfolio.
Adding private assets does not necessarily diversify the total portfolio if they replicate growth, credit, leverage, or other exposures already held elsewhere.
The allocation between implementation vehicles can then be guided by factors such as:
![]() |
For a given risk exposure, institutions with higher liquidity capacity and appetite may allocate more capital to less liquid vehicles if the expected incremental return justifies it.
Institutions with lower liquidity capacity may prefer public or more liquid options, even if expected returns are lower, because liquidity adds value to the total portfolio.
The optimal allocation is not universal; it depends on how each implementation choice affects the institution’s total portfolio.
Public and Private Markets as Partly Substitutable Implementations
This does not make public and private markets perfect substitutes.
Private markets may provide access to companies, projects, structures and control rights that are not available in public markets. Public markets offer price discovery, transparency, scalability, lower costs and more efficient rebalancing.
The relevant comparison is therefore not whether one form is inherently superior. It is whether the additional return or diversification expected from a particular implementation adequately compensates the institution for the liquidity, complexity, cost and governance capacity it consumes.
Alternatives Are Becoming Less Alternative
The term “alternative investments” is less relevant now that private equity, private credit, infrastructure, and real estate are established components of institutional portfolios.
At the same time, the boundary between public and private markets has become more flexible.
Secondary markets have grown. Continuation vehicles provide new ways to extend or transfer ownership. Evergreen and semi-liquid structures offer investors more flexible commitment and redemption options.
These developments expand the range of implementation choices available to institutions. However, they do not eliminate illiquidity.
Secondary-market exits may require discounts, especially during stress. Evergreen structures may allow periodic redemptions, but underlying assets can remain illiquid. In some cases, liquidity risk is transferred to the fund structure or managed through redemption limits.
Therefore, contractual liquidity should not be confused with the actual economic liquidity of underlying assets.
The Asset-Allocation Decision
Under a Total Portfolio Approach, the allocation process should be reframed.
The institution first determines the economic risks it wishes to own. Next, it assesses how much liquidity, leverage, complexity, and manager dependence it can tolerate. Finally, it selects the mix of public and private implementation vehicles that provides the most attractive expected contribution to the total portfolio.
The central questions become:
These questions require more than market analysis. They require a clear understanding of the institution’s liabilities, cash-flow profile, governance, stakeholder behaviour, and investment horizon.
A defined-benefit pension plan with stable contributions and predictable benefit payments may have greater capacity for illiquid investments than an institution with uncertain withdrawals or significant collateral needs. However, a long-term investor is not always a long-horizon investor in practice. Governance, funding pressures, and stakeholder behaviour may limit the institution’s ability to remain invested.
Looking Ahead
Public and private markets will continue to differ in important ways. Liquidity, valuation, governance, fees, control rights and implementation complexity all matter.
But those differences should not define the economic structure of the portfolio.
The more useful starting point is the risk the institution wants to own. Liquidity then helps determine how that risk should be implemented and how much flexibility the institution is willing to give up in pursuit of additional return.
The objective is not to maximise private-market exposure or preserve traditional asset-class boundaries. It is to construct a total portfolio in which each investment earns its place through the risk it contributes, the liquidity it consumes and the role it plays in fulfilling the mandate.
Institutions are not rewarded simply for owning asset classes. They are rewarded for bearing compensated risks that they are structurally and organisationally prepared to manage.
* Images generated using ChatGPT





Comments
Post a Comment