Back to Basics: The Mandate Still Comes First

 

I recently attended two investment conferences in London. The topics were quite different.
One focused on how asset owners are moving beyond traditional asset allocation toward more adaptive, total-portfolio thinking. The other focused on manager research in private equity and the role of external managers within the broader portfolio.
Despite the different subject matter, both discussions led back to the same conclusion:
The mandate still comes first.
Institutional investment frameworks have become increasingly sophisticated. We spend considerable time on expected returns, factor exposures, liquidity, benchmarks, manager selection, portfolio construction and implementation.
All of these are important. But they are downstream decisions.
The more fundamental question is what the fund must ultimately achieve.
That requires clarity on a small number of issues that should sit at the centre of the investment process:
 
These are not preliminary questions to be answered once and then set aside. They should continue to shape capital allocation, risk-taking and implementation over time.
The mandate is therefore more than a statement of objectives. It is the governing framework that connects the institution’s purpose to the portfolio.
In total-portfolio construction, this means starting with the risks the institution is willing and able to take, rather than with predetermined asset-class allocations. The objective is not to optimise each portfolio in isolation, but to understand how individual exposures contribute to the fund’s overall risk, return, liquidity, and resilience.
That distinction matters.
An asset class can deliver strong standalone returns and still contribute little to the broader portfolio. Two apparently different investments may provide very similar economic exposures. And an allocation that appears efficient in normal markets may look very different once liquidity needs, funding requirements or stressed conditions are taken into account.
The same logic applies to private markets.
Manager research should focus on track record, team stability, sourcing capability, sector expertise, and alignment of interests. But manager selection should not begin with the manager.
It should begin with the role the portfolio needs that manager to perform.
Is the strategy providing a return source that is difficult to access elsewhere? Does it add genuine diversification or increase an exposure the fund already has? Is the expected return sufficient to compensate for illiquidity, fees, complexity and governance demands?
And this is where portfolio context becomes very real. When distributions slow while capital calls continue, questions of pacing, liquidity and portfolio capacity stop being secondary implementation matters. They become part of the investment decision itself.
An excellent manager, or a compelling asset class, can still be the wrong choice if it does not serve the fund’s mandate.
This is also where governance matters.
A clear mandate provides the basis for delegation and accountability. It allows boards and investment teams to distinguish between strategic objectives and implementation decisions. It also creates a common reference point for assessing whether risk is being taken deliberately and whether individual decisions remain consistent with the objectives of the total fund.
Without that anchor, complexity can turn into fragmented decision-making. Individual portfolios, managers or strategies may each look sensible on their own while the total portfolio becomes less coherent.
Returning to the mandate is therefore not a rejection of sophisticated investment thinking.
It is what gives that sophistication direction.
Back to basics does not mean simplistic.
It means maintaining a clear line from institutional purpose to risk, from risk to portfolio design, and from portfolio design to implementation and accountability.
The two London discussions reinforced a principle that applies across asset allocation, portfolio construction and manager selection:
Good investment decisions rarely begin with an asset class, a product or a manager. They begin with the mandate, and every subsequent decision should be tested against it.
* Images generated using ChatGPT

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Looking Beyond Asset Classes: A Factor Lens for Investing

Why Mean-Variance Optimisation Isn’t Enough

The Mandate Comes First